Saturday, February 8, 2014

Virtual Reality and a note on Kinect

There's been a lot of talk lately about the Oculus Rift, and a few other companies (Sony, Valve) apparently working on something of their own. Some people are arguing that virtual reality (VR) is the future of gaming. On the surface, it may certainly seem like it. I've heard hands-on reports of the Oculus Rift that sound like an amazing, truly immersive experience the likes of which we can't even imagine with our little flat-panel displays.

But VR by itself can't be the next big thing. It needs something to drive it. There's going to need to be a "killer app" for the device, something truly ground-breaking, easily accessible, and (the biggest bit) affordable. Those last two also means it has to be able to run on pretty much anything, as far as a PC goes, or to run it off of existing hardware like a Playstation 4 or Xbox One. You have to make the initial investment small enough to be affordable to most people, and enough that they'll think that it's worth it.

The problem is, I don't think there is such a killer app just yet. And right now, Oculus Rift needs a pretty hefty PC to push it. Not necessarily just the VR portion, either, that's not really any more demanding than normal 3D. But in order to feel realistic, it's going to have to look realistic, too, which means using some of the latest rendering technology and the most powerful game engines out there. One of the more impressive demos I've heard about is from an upcoming title called Star Citizen, a science-fiction game using the CryEngine. CryEngine is certainly up to the task, and creates easily some of the best graphics in gaming today. But it comes at a cost of needing a pretty beefy rig to run it effectively (which is why, even though it's available on consoles, it remains a stigma of high-end PC gaming).

As it is, I think VR will be, at best, a niche item for the time being. In a few more years, maybe with the next console generation, we can see VR packaged in the box, automatically putting it into millions of homes across the world. But until then, I think VR users will remain in the minority. Maybe I'll be part of that. Maybe I won't. We'll have to wait and see.

Now, I just wanted to throw in a quick word about Kinect, based on a discussion I just saw. The question essentially boiled down to "We have the hardware, so where's the software?" With the previous generation, Kinect was an optional thing, and developers tended to shy away from it since they couldn't guarantee a large enough install base to guarantee that their game would sell enough to be profitable. With this new generation, a Kinect is included in the box with every Xbox One, and yet developers are still shying away from it. Why? I think the answer is pretty obvious, really... people still don't want to actually play the damn thing. Given the choice, I think most Xbox One owners would rather unplug it and put it in a closet. Gamers still want the same experience they had before, and it's already been proven that Kinect's control style is completely unsuited to the "hardcore" experience. So right away, any game marketed strictly to Kinect would have to be a niche title, probably one aimed at younger gamers (which isn't even the primary market for the system as a whole). Also consider that, as an exclusive piece of hardware, the concept of a multiplatform release is thrown right out the window, further limiting the potential profits from the game's release. Which, in turn, reduces the amount of money a developer is willing to invest in the title. Sort of a downward spiral, really. Developers are going where the money is, which is in the opposite direction from Kinect. They're sticking with what works... big-budget AAA titles spread across every available platform.

Sorry, Microsoft, but I think the plan has already failed. You built it, and they did not come.

On a small gaming note, I've found a cure for incontinence in the form of Red Barrels' Outlast. Because this game will make you shit yourself in fright. I don't know what in the hell I was thinking downloading it.

Wednesday, October 9, 2013

Would you like something different? Or just the same **** as before?

So recently, there was an article about the game Beyond: Two Souls. The discussion, among other things, touched on how "risky" it was to make a game featuring a main character that's female. According to the article, creator David Cage was actually told by other developers the following statement:

“Oh, do you really think gamers want to be this young girl? They want to be guys, dudes, with big muscles and big guns.”

Short answer: No. Long answer: No.

The first thing that came to mind was THIS VIDEO by Jim Sterling, wherein he discusses the concept of what people "want" versus what they actually buy. His example uses focus groups, where a bunch of gamers say that they want games just like Call of Duty, so all of the developers make games like Call of Duty. And then no one buys them. Why? Because all those people who said they wanted Call of Duty already have Call of Duty.

In a lot of game genres, like the Modern Miliary Shooter (MMS) that I just mentioned, there's usually a clear leader, one game that stands above the rest. Everything else is just a copy, a cheap knockoff. And gamers know it. That's why they're not bothering to buy any of them. The market is flooded with a million copies of every kind of game out there. And the majority of them are a complete waste of time.

The point of all this is that I've started seeing more validity in games that break the mold, that really go outside of what we expect and don't simply copy other games. These tend to be smaller titles, perhaps "testing the waters" to see if gamers are interested. And so far, they seem to be. Sony has gone so far as to "open the doors" for independent developers to release their games on the upcoming Playstation 4, in order to allow gamers to get a taste of all the other good stuff out there, beyond just what the big AAA developers throw at us.

In regards to female protagonists, that alone certainly isn't enough to make a game interesting (nor is it enough to condemn it). It's cosmetic, really, just a different skin over the player character, if there's nothing else in the game to make her interesting. A good example would be the recently-released Remember Me, a game that caught a lot of flak before release because it had not only a female protagonist, but a black female protagonist. Unlike the majority, this actually piqued my interest. They were obviously comfortable enough in their creation to eschew gaming tradition, maybe this was going to be something really neat. But then the reviews came along, and despite an intriguing premise, it seems that the developers forgot to make a decent game to put this interesting character into. It was a by-the-numbers game like a dozen others I've played these last few years. Trying to shake things up in a mediocre game by adding just a different protagonist doesn't change the fact that it's still just a mediocre game. Before release, all the news was about the player character. After release, it was all about how the game just wasn't very good. Which is sad, because it seems like it had a lot of potential. I may still give it a chance later on when it goes on sale on Steam or PSN.

Now that Beyond: Two Souls has been released, I've seen something very interesting in its reviews; extreme levels of polarization. There's a very wide spectrum of review scores, ranging from very high to very low. Well, maybe "ranging" isn't the right word.. they're either very high OR they're very low. There doesn't seem to be a middle ground with this one. No "meh, it's okay". It's either the most amazing thing ever crafted by human hands or it's not even worth the few cents of metal and plastic that it's printed on.

Ironically, the game's predecessor, Heavy Rain, likewise a very polarizing game, was one that I said "Eh, it's not bad" about. I neither loved nor hated it. But I sure as hell gave it the chance, because it was something different. The same chance I'm giving to Beyond (and so far, it's paying off).

One statement that occasionally shows up when discussing games as different as Heavy Rain and Beyond, and any other game that doesn't quite fit genre stereotypes (like Journey, The Stanley Parable, or Dear Esther), is the old "If you didn't like it, then you didn't 'get' it" trope. In most cases, this is just bullshit spewed by fanboys, but in some cases, like Beyond, I think it actually has a small element of truth. A small element, mind you (I still think the statement in general is BS). The games aren't brilliant, they're not Game of the Year contenders, but they are different from anything else. And that's enough to scare some people off. They keep wanting to compare it to other similar games, but there simply aren't any. David Cage and the (admittedly very talented) staff at Quantic Dream seem to have created a whole new genre, and a lot of people just aren't quite sure what to make of it yet.

That's not saying that the negative reviews are wrong.. they're part of the picture. Some people just don't like this kind of game, and I'm okay with that. It doesn't lessen my enjoyment in the slightest. But I think it should be important for game reviewers to at least admit to the fact that, professional opinion aside, they just personally don't care for this particular genre of games. I think reviews would be a lot more balanced if reviewers would take things like that into account. Rather than going on and on about how bad the game is (to you), point out the good stuff, and how it may appeal to certain people, and how it may turn off certain other people. It's okay for a review to say "some people will like this, and some people won't". Dismissing something just because it's different isn't the way to push the industry forward. And we desperately need that right now.

Sunday, June 30, 2013

World War Z

I want to make one thing very clear from the get-go. I have not seen the film, nor do I have any intention of doing so. Not even waiting for rental, as I don't really want to spend any money on it, so I think I'll be waiting for Netflix. Now I'll tell you why, and it's quite simple: It's because I read the book.

Yes, it's actually based on a book. You'd never know it, though. Aside from the title, it shares absolutely nothing in common with the apparent "source material". We've seen movies like this before, of course.. film adaptations based on books that are drastically different from the source material as to piss off the fans of the books. But even then, despite the "oh, it just has the same name" argument that book fans use, those films usually have at least some elements from the book. That could be character names, the overall plot arc, or some minor details or character moments here and there, etc.

In this case, though, there's none of that. Literally, none. What little there was originally was excised when they decided to reshoot the entire last act of the film. And when all was said and done, it really was just the name that stuck around.

Well, you could argue that they both have zombies. But even that's not entirely true. In the book, we're presented with the more traditional walking dead.. the slow, rotting corpse mumbling "braaaaaaains" as it shuffles slowly after our heroes. Okay, I made that last bit up about the mumbling, but you get the idea. They're classic zombies. In the film, however, they're presented more like the victims of the rage virus from 28 Days Later, super-fast and incredibly violent, with hundreds and thousands of them flowing over the cities like a flood (while it's a cool effect, it does rather boggle the mind).

So, out of my desire to support the author of the book, I choose not to spend any of my hard-earned money to see World War Z.

Now, while we're on the subject, I do have an idea as to how the book could be successfully adapted. But not into a film. I don't think there's any way to really adapt this into a two-hour film that will make a gazillion dollars on opening weekend. It's just not that kind of book. My idea is simple: A television series.

You see, the book is written from the point of view of a survivor of the Zombie War, who has collected incredible stories of survival from around the entire world, of mankind really stretched to the ragged edge and the amazing things that these people did to make it through it. As a TV series, you could actually do each of these stories, documentary-style, with each episode of the show focused on a different story, from a different perspective, all connected by the crew putting together the documentary and the interviewer, who would take the place of the original book's fictitious "author". You could still make an amazing zombie show out of it by doing in-universe "dramatic reenactments" of the events as told, so we'd actually get to see these people's stories unfold in classic zombie style.

Seriously, if you're a fan of the genre, and you have the chance, you owe it to yourself to read the book. But be forewarned: If you've only seen the film and want to get more, the book will probably not be what you're looking for. It's far better, in my opinion, but don't expect anything of the film to be there.

Friday, May 31, 2013

So.. the new Xbox...

Not much to say here.. you've probably seen it all already. I'm not a fan.

I bought an Xbox360 a while after it was launched, and I really only enjoyed, truly enjoyed, two games. Forza 3, which tided me over until Gran Turismo 5 came along, and Fable II. And then I realized that I hadn't turned the thing on in about two years and I sold it. And, I don't really miss it much.

So far, Microsoft isn't doing anything to make me want to jump in line to get their new system (which, interestingly, has the same name as my phone.. the "One").

I've seen a lot of talk about it online, of course, and some fans that swear this new voice-control will be the true next generation of home entertainment. I'll only say this on the subject: It's not going to work half as well as you think it will, much less than you hope it will. MS has a history of making things look very good on stage to get you to buy something (like the original Kinect), but then when you actually get the thing home, it can't really do any of the things that they said it could. And those things that it does do, takes screaming at the top of your lungs and e-nun-ci-at-ing far more clearly than a normal human ever does in conversation.

And let's not even talk about privacy concerns.

As for the used game argument.. really, it doesn't bother me much, because I don't buy used games on principle. But I do think it's pretty ridiculous that gamers are going to have to enter registration codes (i.e. "CD Keys") on console games. That used to be one of the big advantages of console games over PC games. Apparently not any more.

Yes, I'll be watching both of the big press conferences in a week and a half at E3. One for excitement, the other for amusement. I'll let you decide which is which.

Tuesday, May 21, 2013

The Daftest of Punks are Back

So, Random Access Memories, the new album from Daft Punk has hit the shelves, and here's my take. I won't be long. First off, the album overall is fantastic. Secondly (and negatively for some), this is NOT your daddy's Daft Punk.

So let's start with #1: The fantastic album. There's thirteen songs on here, eight of which I have lumped in my "best of" DP collection (which is only nineteen tracks, so RAM has more songs in there than any of their previous albums).

Notice I said "songs" and not "tracks". This is a much more mature effort than their previous albums, with a real attempt to push into full-blown mainstream song releases and not just techno/funk/dance music that highlighted their first album. It's also much "softer" sounding, without the thumping bass that we've heard before (it's still there, but much subdued). The closest thing in style from their previous albums is the track "Verdis Quo" from their second album Discovery, but imagine that woven with a full song's worth of lyrics, rather than just a repeating segment or sample.

The overall sound is something I would describe as a mix of 80s soft rock (think Toto or Asia, maybe Kansas) and jazz, with some mild electronica here and there.

So, in tone, this album is a severe departure from their previous work. But, surprisingly, it still feels like Daft Punk. You can instantly tell that this is put together by the same minds that rocked the house in 2007's Alive live album. The instant I heard "Get Lucky", I knew this was Daft Punk, despite it being so different in tone and sound.

Oddly enough, I find myself at odds with the majority of the user reviews I've read, which state that their favorite tracks are "Lose Yourself to Dance", and "Touch". These are the tracks I actually liked the least, and my favorites include the first two tracks, "Give Life Back to Music" and "The Game of Love" (actually "sang" by Daft Punk's own Thomas Bangalter instead of one of the guest artists), "Instant Crush" (which has a truly addictive chorus), the first single "Get Lucky", "Motherboard" (strongly reminiscent of their work on Tron: Legacy), "Doin' it Right", and "Contact", which is the most "old-school" track on the album.

So what's in store for Daft Punk after this? Word is that Random Access Memories was supposed to be a hell of a lot bigger. According to the Wikipedia article, they recorded enough material for four CDs. Which means there's another three hours or so of material that we haven't heard yet. Maybe they'll release it bit by bit over the next few years, maybe it'll end up in their live shows, who knows. Maybe some of that sounds different than what we finally got on the album. Maybe some of it's more "old school". Can't wait to find out.

So yeah.. it's different. But you know what?

I like it.

Sunday, March 17, 2013

Is Ignorance Bliss?

Sometimes I think it's not worthwhile to keep up with the ins and outs of the gaming industry. There's almost too much information, and not all of it good. And it's starting to effect how much I enjoy some titles.

A couple of recent examples: Aliens: Colonial Marines (ACM) and SimCity (SC). We'll start with ACM.

Some of you may have heard about the issues surrounding this title. Most of it has to do with a lot of drama in the development of the game. The developer went on and on about how much they loved the franchise, and how they were finally going to give the fans the "true" Aliens game that they've wanted all these years. What really happened is that they couldn't give two shits about the game, and instead farmed it out to various lower-tier third-party developers to actually make the game, and put out a game that was very different than what they promised us. So much so that people have openly accused them of lying, outright false advertisement, largely based on a "live" demo shown at E3 last year, nearly all of which did not appear in the final game.

That said, the game actually isn't bad. It's just not as good as it could have been, as it should have been. The graphics are a little "meh" most of the time (but other times downright stunning, like the exteriors of LV-426). The AI is a little bit on the stupid side. Okay, maybe more than a "little". But, really, it plays fairly well (on PC, at any rate, although it could be that my system is merely muscling it's way through), and it's not downright buggy or crashing or anything.

But I wonder how I would feel about the game if I hadn't seen those early reviews? If I didn't already know going into it that it wasn't going to be as great as I thought it was?

Which brings me to SimCity. Oh, dear.

What started out as a promising game turned into a nightmare for many, as the game was plagued with server issues at launch. Plenty of paying customers were unable to play the game that they purchased for a week or more. Thankfully, those issues have been largely resolved, but now new issues are coming to light.

That always-online requirement? EA/Maxis said it was due to heavy server-side calculations that were occurring, that most of the detailed simulations you were seeing were actually being done on their end, to offload the extreme stress from your lowly little PCs. This was, apparently, the cause of some of the server issues they were having at launch.

Turns out that was a load of bollocks. The game is, in fact, run entirely offline, and if not for their artificial 20-minute timeout, the game will run just fine indefinitely without a network connection at all. It's actually coded into the game to force itself to quit if it can't talk to the Maxis servers for twenty minutes. If you change that one line of code, the game will run forever, and perfectly fine, for any length of time.

So it turns out that the only reason the servers were there was to facilitate inter-city regional interactions between players (which makes sense for multiplayer) and to save your game, since the only copy of your city is in the cloud. Isn't it? No, actually, that's stored on your PC, too, and just uploaded to their servers at regular intervals and when you quit. And while the servers are necessary for multiplayer, if you choose to run an entire region all on your onesies, the inter-city processing is so minimal (as shown by users tracking exactly what information was sent back and forth between the servers whenever they ran multiple cities), that it could easily be run on your PC as well.

The city size limit? Artificial. It's bound only by their invisible walls, not by any limitation in processing or graphical power. Users have already broken out of those walls and affected the region around them.

One reason for all this, one that I happen to agree with, is the idea that the game was originally intended to be a browser-based game, likely integrated into Facebook or some such. Those limitations make a lot more sense when you look at it that way. But then they decided to make it a full standalone game released at $60, without removing any of those browser-based limitations. And now they're catching a ton of flak for it.

The problem is that I know all these things. I've been keeping up with the news, reading the forums and the news sites. And, frankly, it's starting to ruin the game for me. Now, when I play it, I can't help but see those invisible walls, and the ludicrously stupid traffic AI routines, and forced limitations (like game speed) because their servers can't handle the load. If I hadn't read any of that, I would probably be enjoying the game a lot more than I am.

With something like this, that you look forward to, and you initially enjoy before hearing other people complain... is it better to remain ignorant of the flaws, if you yourself don't notice them? Sometimes... maybe it is.

Microsoft's Problem: Microsoft

This one's been coming for a while, I just haven't gotten around to writing it yet, but it came up again on the NeoGAF forums today, so I figured I'd go ahead and put it into words.

This revelation occurred to me shortly after the launch of Windows 8. Like most tech-heads, I passed on Win8 because it had absolutely nothing to offer me. Worse, it would have made my system more difficult to work with and to do the things I do.

When it comes to computers, it's true that many people don't know that much about the technical side of things. But chances are, they know someone who does. So there's usually someone they can ask, besides the salesman at Best Buy, about what they should and should not purchase. This is what happened to Windows 8. Everyone knew about it thanks to Microsoft's aggressive marketing, but even the people that didn't know any better were warned off by the people that did.

Here's Microsoft's problem: They can't see beyond their own marketing. Every salesman loves to talk about how great their product is, it's part of being a salesman. But a good salesman also knows the truth about the product, even if it's something they never talk about. They know the areas to avoid discussion, they know how to downplay faults and lean the conversation over to the positives. But the important thing is that they're aware of the issues, and why their product isn't for everyone.

Except Microsoft. They appear to actually believe the shit that comes out of their mouth at trade shows like E3 or on their television commercials. In the case of Windows 8, the result is that they're genuinely baffled by the low sales figures. It's true that people aren't buying Windows 8. Microsoft blames the OEM manufacturers for "not making enticing hardware" that can easily be sold with Win8 on it (but wait, MS.. I thought that Win8 itself was reason enough?). The manufacturers have it right.. they're blaming Microsoft for forcing them to install an operating system that no one wants to buy. Microsoft can't see this side of the argument because they refuse to believe that people actually don't want to buy their amazing product.

Seriously, this is their problem... they honestly cannot understand the concept of someone not wanting to buy Windows 8. It's so incredible, it's so amazing, it's so revolutionary, everyone must want it, but why are they not buying it? They're placing the blame on everyone but themselves, refusing to acknowledge that they didn't actually make something that real people want.

This is something I've seen crop up now and again with different companies, but Microsoft is far and away the worst at it right now. They believe in their own marketing so much that they expect everyone else to do so as well, for no other reason than because they said so. Windows 8 is the second coming of the PC operating system because Microsoft said it was. Kinect is the true future of gaming because Microsoft said it was. Surface is the true tablet experience because Microsoft said it was. And they can't see beyond that "because we said so" mentality. And they're going to continue pushing crap onto the market, and they're going to continue being surprised at the lack of sales, and eventually they're going to run themselves into the mud doing it.

On the subject of Kinect, I think MS is about to create a schism in the gaming industry by packing the thing in with every Xbox Infinity (or whatever they're going to call it). They're going to push Kinect so hard (most likely demanding that all games feature some kind of Kinect functionality) that developers will stop making games for them in favor of PS4/PC games that use traditional control schemes. It's too early to tell, really, but that's my prediction, we'll see what happens.

Unfortunately, marketing can be a powerful tool. Look at the recent announcement of the Samsung Galaxy S4 smartphone. Underwhelming and second-best in nearly every way to the HTC One, but destined to sell ten times more because of marketing. When it comes to computers, people ask the tech-heads around them. For some reason, they don't do this with smartphones, even though they are just computers themselves. My recommendation: Buy the HTC One. That's what I'm buying.

Saturday, March 9, 2013

SimCity Followup

Given the events of the last week, I felt a followup to my last post was required, regarding the now-released SimCity game.

If you're not up to speed, the gist of the argument is that EA/Maxis was apparently unprepared for the initial rush of gamers on the first few days of launch, resulting in a large number of people being unable to play the game due to the EA servers being inaccessible. This was mostly limited to login issues, and once logged in, gameplay was usually okay. But a few people, myself included, experienced certain issues in-game as well, such as lag, being unable to share resources between cities, or being unable to start a new city or region (even though I was playing in "Private" mode).

Now, the first response to my last post, wherein I essentially said that always-online was okay, is the old "I told you so". But is that really the case? At no point in my previous post did I mention launch problems, and I even mentioned Diablo III (D3) as an example of an always-online game that I was okay with, noting that D3 itself had a huge number of issues at launch.

But I just mentioned general-purpose gameplay. "I just want to play single player", or "I want to be able to play on the train without internet". That's what everyone was complaining about before launch, not a fear that the game would be unplayable.

Unfortunately, EA's reaction to this has been less than stellar. They knew how many pre-orders were done, they knew how much load was going to be on the servers, but they didn't prepare for it. After the fact, they just said pointless things like "We're working on it", without providing any clear information on what the problem was or what they were doing. At one point even going so far as to say that it was the gamers' fault, that the game was so awesome that people just kept playing, taking up valuable server space and preventing new players from joining. And then, worst of all, actually disabling in-game features to reduce the hammering that their servers were getting. I haven't talked to a single person  yet who's okay with that part of it.

They've since announced that they'll be offering a free game from their library as an apology to anyone who owns SimCity. That's all well and good, but I have the sneaking suspicion the selection will be pretty poor, that I'll end up picking something from the list that I don't really have all that much interest in (the fact that it will play exclusively through Origin is not a selling point, either, as I like that service far less than Steam or Uplay).

Anyway, I just wanted to clarify my stance from earlier, and that I do still stick to those ideas, in spite of the launch issues that SimCity suffered.

Sunday, March 3, 2013

Is Always-Online Really the Devil?

So I've been chatting on several boards lately regarding the upcoming release of SimCity, and I'm surprised by the number of people put off by the whole "Always-on" DRM that the game employs. Well, there's a few things to consider. First off, it's not exclusively just DRM. The game does feature a strong multiplayer component. While I don't necessarily feel I'll be joining in much myself, I understand that it really does need to be there.

Now, this hearkens back to another discussion a year or so ago about Diablo III, and its always-on requirement. The same kind of outrage hit the 'net that time, too. And at first, I joined in. I mean, it was a single-player game, after all, much like SimCity. I didn't think that it was necessary to always be connected.

Then it hit me: I'm always online anyway. What f'in difference did it make? I use Steam, for cryin' out loud.. that's an always-on solution, too. Yes, yes, I know it has an "offline mode", but to be honest, I've never once felt the need to use it. I'm not one of those "mobile" gamers who likes to carry around a high-end gaming laptop so I can play Crysis 3 on the go. I have one gaming system, and it's my PC. I don't even game on my tablet. And really, if you're that much into gaming that you have a ridiculously expensive laptop that can run all that stuff, then it's probably worth your while to be able to get that thing online just about anywhere. It's more than possible today. Get a wi-fi hotspot, tether your phone, or just buy a laptop that has LTE built right into it. I'm sure they make that kind of thing by now, don't they? If not, they should. That's a freebie, Alienware, off you go.

Online is not only about multiplayer. Even for single-player games, it's about sharing. I can, if I want, link my games with Facebook or Twitter or any of those, and then everyone will know when I get the latest achievement or whatever. And that requires a constant internet connection.

And yes, I'm one of those non-social gamers who tends to play single-player titles. But I'm okay with "always online". You know why? Because I'm always online. And so are you.

Friday, December 21, 2012

Is PC gaming truly dead?

An interesting discussion was brought up the other day on the NeoGAF forums. The initial question asked was "Will next-gen console hardware be more powerful than current PCs?"

My initial reaction was simple and straightforward.

Then, as I read through the thread, someone brought up a good point, one that I hadn't considered: How long since we've actually seen a PC game? I mean, a real PC game? Think about it; just about everything released these days is a port from console, or at least built with console in mind. The result has skewed the mindset of PC gamers into something different than it used to be.

The crux of the argument is that PC gamers have gotten used to running everything at absolute maximum settings, and getting stellar performance out of it. I can load up the latest big game, and play it at a higher resolution than the consoles, in a way that looks a lot better, and at a much higher framerate. The problem is that, because this generation has been filled with console games ported to PC, with its much more powerful hardware, this has become the norm. All games run at 1080p60 (1920x1080 Full-HD resolution, at 60 frames per second, the maximum that the average PC monitor can display).

The user in question reminded us of the fact that this wasn't always the case... maximum settings at good framerates used to be reserved for only the most expensive übercomputer, one that the average PC gamer (who spends a good amount of money on a system to begin with) could never hope to afford. That's the whole reason PC games have all those settings in the first place, is scalability. The option to turn something down that's slowing down performance, in order to get the game to run better. In a "true" PC game, it was impossible to run it at maximum settings, at a playable framerate, anyway. The last "true" game we've seen that does this is the original Crysis. To this day, the game won't run at 1080p60 even on my system (which is a bit of a beast). And that game's seven years old.

It's not just the console ports, though. I do have some games that are PC-exclusive... Hard Reset comes to mind. Yes, it has all those options to turn down to improve performance. But, to be honest, I never had to.. I could run the game out of the box at 1080p60 at maximum settings. For whatever reason, while it was designed for PC gamers from a gameplay and control standpoint, it was built more or less to console specs as far as graphics goes. The game is very pretty, but it's not really doing anything groundbreaking that can't be done on a console.

There are still many PC-exclusives, of course. RTS games like Starcraft II, multiplayer shooters like Planetside 2. Various complicated RPGs and MMOs that can only be run using a "controller" with 104 buttons. But none of them are designed to push PCs to the limit anymore. None of them are pushing photorealistic graphics that will bring even the mightest PC to its knees. Crytek claims that the upcoming Crysis 3 will do this, but it's based on the same engine as the previous game, which runs fine, and is also scalable to consoles. While I do believe they plan on making the PC version noticeably better than its console bretheren this time, I don't believe I'll have too much trouble running it (my PC meets the specs of their "high performance" recommendation). In terms of "Yay, a real PC game!!", I may wind up happy if I have to turn some of the settings down a little.

So think about it, fellow gamers with beastly machines... When was the last time you had to turn something down? And how much did it bug you to have to do it?

That said, I don't believe that the PC is dead as a gaming platform, and that's not the point of all this. But we're just another gaming platform now.. Playstation, Xbox, PC. And I'll continue playing that way, to be sure. But it certainly isn't as special as it used to be.

Saturday, August 25, 2012

Prometheus vs. Expectations

It's taken me much longer to write this than I intended (and even longer to post it), and part of this will be discussing why.

In all my time, I don't think I've ever seen a film polarize an audience the way Prometheus has. There doesn't seem to be any middle ground for this one. "Meh, it was okay..." just doesn't exist. There's the positives, the folks that me that really liked it, and then there's the negatives, the folks that flat-out hate it, that utterly despise it as one of the worst pieces of celluloid to come out of Hollywood in the last three decades. That sounds like overkill because it is, but those are the opinions I've seen.

From what I've seen, I think the Negative Nancys are actually the minority, although they pretend to be the majority. They're the most vocal, and the loudest by far, posting their opinions all over the internet, which gives them the appearance of being a much bigger presence than they really are. Those of us who like it tend to be quieter on the subject.

The overall problem, I believe, comes from the expectations that people had. They wanted another Alien, plain and simple. After all, it's the same sci-fi universe, an expansion of the same story, by the same director, even. It had to be the same, right? And it wasn't.. not even close. So they came out bawling about how horrible the film was. Despite the fact that the director, writers, cast, and crew had all been saying for years that it wasn't going to be the Alien film that people were expecting.

Now, let me say this before we get too much further: The film isn't perfect. In fact, if you read reviews and posts from the people that liked it, I'm pretty sure none of them are saying it's perfect, either. I'm not going to spend a lot of time "defending" the film, or trying to come up with explanations for the nitpicks that people didn't like about it. I acknowledge that the film has problems (what film doesn't?) but they don't impact my enjoyment of the film in any way, and that's the important part. Note that I'm not saying the problems don't exist.. I'm just ignoring them because frankly, I don't care.

The only point I'll make on that subject is in response to a post I read on a forum, where one of the Negative Nancys said something to the effect of "Since when has Hollywood had to resort to things like this?" They were referring specifically to the way the scientist characters behaved, doing "stupid things" for "no reason except to advance the plot".

My response was simple, straightforward, and accurate: "Since around 1910."

Seriously. Hollywood has always relied on characters' actions furthering the plot, whether they make sense or not. You could name practically any movie in existence, and I'll be able to find a part where a character does something silly, inane, or just plain stupid, that advances the plot in some way. And I can do that to movies that I (and others) consider great masterpieces and classics. The idea that somehow Prometheus did something that other movies don't is, itself, pretty stupid.

This is another example of the film being held to a different standard than other movies. While such "mistakes" can get by with other films, even other fantasy/sci-fi films, it's okay, but it's somehow a horrid blight on cinema when Prometheus does the same thing. Ridley Scott himself said "It's not a science class, it's a movie."

One part I find particularly amusing is how much of the blame is laid at the feet of Damon Lindelhof. I actually feel bad for the guy as to how much flak he's taking about this film. Aside from the fact that we don't actually know what was Lindelhof and what was John Spaihts (the original writer), the part I find funny is that people seem to think that Ridley Scott didn't notice all these "issues". That either Lindelhof was standing behind him with a gun to his head, forcing him to shoot the movie that he wrote, or that Ridley was too stupid to notice how "bad" the film was and simply shot what he was given. Neither of which could possibly be true. I know for a fact that the rolling-donut Juggernaut at the end of the film (if you've seen it, you know what I'm referring to) was Ridley's idea from the beginning, and even influenced the design of the ship itself to facilitate that scene (the original ship from Alien was not nearly as rounded, and would not have rolled half as well). The sad part of this is that Lindelhof is rumored to not be involved with the proposed sequel, and I wonder whether that decision is based solely on the public opinion that all of the flaws in Prometheus are "his fault", regardless of whether it's true.

People need to learn to have realistic expectations of films, and the ability accept a film for what it is instead of what we want it to be. I'll admit that Prometheus wasn't exactly the same as what I thought it would be, but it wasn't too far off, and it was overall just as good as I expected it to be.

Prometheus is not a perfect movie. If such a thing even exists, there are only a tiny handful of films that I would classify as such (I can only think of one offhand, with another as a close second). And none of them are directed by Ridley Scott.

Saturday, July 7, 2012

3D Follow Up

Since my last post regarding how people are doing 3D "wrong", I've done some research, and I've even altered how I play my own 3D games.

Don't mistake me... they're still doing it wrong, just differently than I had originally guessed. My original theory had been that the images for each eye were too far apart. In a very few cases, this still holds true, but in most cases it isn't, as least as far as "deep" effects go.

Long story short, in order to make something appear to be very far away, the separation between the images should be approximately 60cm. This is the average distance between the eyes of a normal person. If the images are 60cm apart, the eyes basically look straight ahead, rather than converging on the monitor that's only two or three feet away.

I've actually increased my 3D settings in most games to match this. That mountain range off in the distance now really appears to be far away. Shallower settings can still provide a level of "depth", but at the cost of immersion.

Since then, I've also discovered what the real problem is with those videos I see on YouTube. It's what's referred to technically as "negative parallax", or in layman's terms, "pop-out"; the effect of something coming out of the screen at the viewer. While this can be very effective in certain situations, in most cases this is the part that comes across as a "gimmick".

Let's examine a couple of examples. I saw a video posted on AVS forum by a user who photographed a flying quadrotor drone in 3D. At certain points in the video, when the drone was only a few feet away from the camera, there was some negative parallax. At several points during the video, I held my hand out toward the screen, and by god, that drone looked like it was absolutely floating directly above my hand. Really amazing stuff.

The problem with some users and games is knowing where to draw the line. I've seen some videos that have almost exclusively negative parallax, where everything is "popping out" of the screen at me. Things like characters, horses, and buildings. These are massive objects, there's no way they can be in front of my 23" monitor that's only a few feet away.

It turns out that's the part that was frustrating to watch.. my eyes were telling me that the objects were closer, while my brain was balking at the idea, insisting that they must be further away. It's similar to what happens when you view 3D content with the left/right eyes reversed (I don't recommend it, by the way, it's incredibly disorienting).

This is the reason why most filmmakers choose the "window" approach. Where almost nothing ever gets closer than screen distance from the audience. Where everything you see is further away from you. This is how I've chosen to play my games, and even at very high depth settings (but not higher than my eyes can handle), the result is extremely immersive and a truly amazing way to play. But as soon as I start pushing the convergence point further out in order to get some of that "pop-out", the effect is ruined. It also muddles with the sense of scale.

So you're still all doing it wrong.. just set your convergence at screen depth. That doesn't mean you won't ever get any pop-out, it just means that when it does happen, it'll be something that's actually supposed to be only a foot or so away from your face. It'll make you suddenly jump back, and then you'll smile and say "that was cool..."

Saturday, June 9, 2012

3D Gamers, You're Doing it Wrong

No, not Hollywood this time. YOU.

There's a reason why so many people look at 3D as being a "gimmick" or nothing more than a sales ploy to sell more (or simply more expensive) movie tickets. It's because a lot of Hollywood does things for effect.. making the 3D "pop" and having things come flying out of the screen at you and so forth. Stupid shit.

What we need to do, as users capable of creating our own 3D content (particularly games), is to show them that it shouldn't be done this way. The problem is, we're not helping. If anything, we're making it worse.

I just got recently purchased a 3D monitor for my computer, and I've been taking the opportunity to see a bunch of 3D content on the internet, such as YouTube and the like (as well as, naturally, trying out every PC game I have). I see a lot of game footage online; gameplay, demos, etc. And on practically every video I see, it's small wonder people say that 3D is too much.. you people have no idea what you're doing with it.

On practically every gameplay video I've seen on YouTube, the person recording it has the 3D depth effect cranked up far beyond the "gimmick" stage into the "I have to cross my eyes to see anything" stage. And they call it "immersive". There's a slider in the NVidia control panel that defaults to 15%. I can tell most of the people out there have it set to somewhere around.. oh.. 100% or so.

Let me give a quick rundown of how 3D works for those that are unfamiliar. The computer renders everything in the scene twice, at different levels of separation. One copy goes to our left eye, one to our right. The further apart they are. Because of the way our eyes focus on things, the further apart the objects are, the further away they appear to be (or are closer to us, popping out of the screen, depending on how the effect is rendered).

The problem when you turn the effect up too high is that objects are too far apart to be able to focus on them. Let's say you have a character on screen, and a tree in the distance. The player character is fairly close to the screen, so the separation isn't that high. On a 23" computer monitor, we're looking at a separation between left and right eye of maybe a quarter of an inch. At a normal distance of around 40" or so, that's not hard for our eyes to focus on. If you look at the screen without your 3D glasses on, the character looks blurry and "doubled".

The tree in the distance, on the other hand, may be three or four inches apart.. without glasses, you can actually see two separate, distinct trees. Because of how far apart they are, your eyes have to pull away from each other in order to see it properly. For most people, our eyes don't actually work that way, and it becomes an effort, and in some cases painful, to actually focus on objects like that. Crossing our eyes toward each other is easier to do, but that only happens on objects that are "closer" to us rather than further away.

The 3D effect is meant to draw you into the experience. Having to contort your eyeballs to see something does exactly the opposite of that, it pulls you out of the experience and reminds you that you're playing a game. And a poorly-calibrated one at that.

The other thing it does, that most people don't stop and think about, is that it will destroy the effect of scale. By having to move your eyes as much as you do to focus on things, it makes it look like the game world is just a small diorama, and you're looking at it through a tiny little camera.

It took me only a matter of minutes of fiddling with 3D to figure out that the effect worked best when it was subtle. Keep the depth to a fairly low setting, so that even the objects far in the distance still have a fairly low separation value, maybe half an inch. What you end up with is a much more immersive feeling, because you're eyes aren't having to fight against themselves in order to focus on anything. Just like in real life! How 'bout that. Your eyes don't hurt focusing on things when you walk your dog, why should they do it when you're raiding the Firelands or killing aliens?

After a few minutes of playing like this, you'll quickly forget that you're playing in 3D. And this is a good thing. You're focusing on the game again, and not the gimmick. But that gameplay will feel deeper to you.. you'll feel a lot more like you're really there. True immersion happens by accident, and not because you're forced into it. The 3D effect should never "wow" you, it should only serve to pull you deeper into the experience.

Some of Hollywood understands this. If you want to see a gimmick-free, proper use of 3D, go see Prometheus. I'll have a full review up later, but I can tell you that this is some of the best use of 3D that I've ever seen, right up there with Avatar for pulling you into the world. And most of the time, you don't even notice it.

So gamers.. turn your 3D down, for Pete's sake. Then those videos you upload to YouTube won't make people eyes try to rip themselves out of their head. Show the rest of them how it's done. Resist the temptation to turn your game into a gimmick, and go subtle. You'll be glad for it in the end.

Saturday, June 2, 2012

E3 is Upon Us! Yaaaaywwwwn!

As some of you probably already know, next week is the Electronic Entertainment Expo (E3) in L.A. The single biggest video game technology show in the world. The place where megaton announcements are made, earth-shattering technology is shown, and mind-blowing presentations and previews are proudly displayed to the masses.

But, by all accounts, absolutely nothing special is going to happen this year. That's it. Let's all go home.

The first problem was brought up by a user on NeoGAF, who asked the simple question "Will there actually be any surprises this year?" He wasn't asking just a general question, though, he was reacting to all of the "pre-E3 announcements" that were made. Pretty much every game company has stated exactly what they'll be displaying at E3 this year, and in many cases, have already shown some of that content in the form of various teasers and images and the like.

So we know Ubisoft is going to show off Assassin's Creed III. EA is going to show off Crysis 3 and SimCity. Sony is going to show off The Last of Us. Microsoft is going to show off Halo 4 and a bunch of Kinect crap that no one wants to see.

So... what's the point of the conference again? There really are no surprises.. we know what we're going to see, and in many cases we've already seen it.

It might be something moderately special for the press that's going to be there, but what about the millions of users who won't be there? All we're going to see are videos and trailers and screenshots from the show, most of which won't be posted until after the show is over. And how is that any different from what we see already? I can go to IGN or GameTrailers, or even just YouTube, and see plenty of videos for every last thing that anyone's planning on showing off. They should save a lot of money and just not have E3 at all, just release a bunch of trailers and screenshots online. That's all those of us at home are going to get out of this conference anyway, so what's the point?

With any luck, we'll all be surprised by last-minute announcements of the next generation of console hardware from Microsoft and Sony, but that's looking less and less likely as we gear up for the show. We would have heard something by now.

So E3 this year looks entirely pointless. I'll probably watch the Microsoft and Sony conferences just to see what's what, but otherwise I really couldn't care less.

Technology Reviewers are Idiots

Long story short, I'm shopping for a 3D computer monitor. None of the local retailers sell them, so I can't just go in and examine them personally to decide which one best suits what I'm looking for. I've narrowed it down pretty far, to LCD IPS displays using passive interleaved 3D. But I'm still not just going to order one sight-unseen without arming myself with some knowledge. This is how I shop for tech.

So, I turn to the experts.. the internet. The internet knows all, right?

It takes all of about four seconds at Google to find a review. The headline is not promising: "3D Fail". So I read the review, and it all looks good, up until the 3D part, where they describe poor depth rendering, and very bad ghosting (where your eyes are seeing parts of the image intended for the other eye).

Let's break these two gripes down, starting with the depth. I'm a visual effects artist, and I've created 3D renders before. The "depth" of an image, meaning the perceived distance between objects in the scene, is controlled by separation. The further apart the left and right images are from each other, the "further" the image will appear to be from the plane of the screen. This goes both ways, depending on how it's set up. It could be closer, or further away. But the result is the same: The depth is directly controlled by how the image is being rendered in the graphics card, and how far apart it's placing those parts of the image.

In other words, it has nothing whatsoever to do with the monitor itself.

The monitor is merely displaying what it's being told to display by the computer that it's connected to. That's why software such as NVidia's 3D Vision includes real time adjustments for things like convergence and depth. You push a button on your keyboard, and the scene depth changes. That doesn't have squat to do with the display.

So why did the reviewer bring it up at all? It's simple, really. He didn't know any better. He hooked it up, and he saw what he saw, but he didn't understand what was happening behind the scenes in software to make that 3D image possible, or how to correctly change it, instead just flailing away on various buttons and controls and saying that it didn't work.

Secondly, he complains about ghosting. Since I've read up on passive 3D displays, I know very well what the leading cause of this is: Poor configuration. Ghosting on passive displays is caused by slight color bleeding, where a color will bleed over into the surrounding pixels. It's more commonly used (intentionally) as antialiasing, to reduce the "jaggies" present on the raw output. 3D software can work around this, if it's configured correctly, and prevent those specific colors from bleeding vertically, which is what causes parts of the image to appear in the other eye's field of view.

Aside from not adjusting any configuration settings in either the monitor or the software, the reviewer also made one other grievous error, which I was only recently pointed to by another user who read the same review: The reviewer connected the monitor to the PC using DVI. The instructions included with the monitor clearly state that 3D only functions properly over the HDMI connection.

So the leading cause of his complaint was actually caused by his own dumbassedness: He hooked it up wrong.

So, the leading "expert" on monitor technology can't even plug the thing in correctly, and then complains loudly about how poor the performance is.

Then comes the worst part of this whole mess: No one else in the English speaking world actually reviews the thing for themselves. Do a Google search for "Asus 3D IPS monitor review" (I won't even bother listing the model number, you'll find it). The first thing you'll find is the CNET review that I'm talking about above. The next two hundred responses will be from other tech websites, all of them doing nothing but retweeting the CNET review.

Seriously.. of all the tech-related websites in the world, only one of them actually laid eyes on the hardware in question, and everyone else just took their word for it. Not a one of them stopped for two seconds to think "Hey, this doesn't sound right..." Again, the reason is simple: They don't know any better, either. They don't understand the technology any more than CNET did, and they have no way of knowing that the reviewer might have made a mistake or two. Or five.

I'm honestly surprised that Asus hasn't filed a lawsuit against CNET over this. That one review has probably single-handedly killed this product for them, because there are no other reviews that state anything other than what CNET did. Every review that anyone reads will be negative in the extreme, and no one will buy the thing.

Another user did point me to a review of the monitor from Romania, who actually hooked it up correctly, and had no real complaints to speak of. But how many of their customers are going to see this review? Not many, I'd wager. Newegg's review section is barren because no one wants to buy the thing.

These are the so-called "experts" that we turn to for help in making purchase decisions. Seemingly unknown to the reviewers themselves, this is actually a pretty big responsibility. I can't see it for myself, so I need someone else to tell me as much as they can about it. But I believe I'm entitled to listen to someone who actually knows what the hell they're doing. I might as well listen to Jim-Bob Jones down the street if this is the kind of crap I'm going to be reading on these websites.

If you can't even plug the thing in correctly, you have no business being an "expert", or posting any kind of review online, especially one that's going to be proliferated across the entire internet. Your ignorance of the very technology you claim to be an "expert" on is not doing any favors for the companies that make these products. I'm half-tempted to buy this monitor just to spite the reviewer.

Friday, May 18, 2012

What's happening to our games?

I was watching some videos from E3, TGS, and GDC from last year, and I saw some things that made me worry about the state of games.

I was tipped off about this from an article on Rock, Paper, Shotgun, which you can read HERE, with a follow-up article HERE. It introduced me to the idea of the "un-game". And now I'm having a hard time not seeing this when I look at some upcoming titles.

The basic idea behind the un-game is that it's an experience that doesn't really have the player do much of anything. Just movement from setpiece to setpiece, cutscene to cutscene. Now, we're not talking about linear games or cinematic titles. Most of those still require the player to actually do something most of the time.

The RPS articles are referring specifically to the highly successful title Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 (MW3). A "game" in which the player is merely an observer and doesn't actually do anything of consequence, you merely follow and watch the NPCs you're with actually do the important things (read the RPS articles for specifics).

The problem is when I look at other titles and start to see some of the same things crop up. Not necessarily to the extent that MW3 does, but things that are bothersome in the idea that the game is essentially telling you how to play it, rather than having the player actually think for themselves. The two examples I'm going to mention are both highly popular (only one has been released to date), which will probably make my opinions of them unpopular. Gears of War 3 and the upcoming reboot of the Tomb Raider franchise.

I was watching a play demo of Gears of War 3 (GOW3) at, I think it was E3 last year. During the demo, a huge creature of some sort was attacking the ship that the player character and NPCs were on. Your character was instructed to lead the creature to a certain part of the ship where it could be more easily killed. I don't remember the specifics, but I do remember that, during the scene on the main deck, the game kept popping up on-screen tips as to what the player should do. When the creature began waving its tentacles around, the game told the player in no uncertain terms that they should "dodge the monster" until the next phase of the battle could begin, at which point the creature latched onto something, and the player was told to "dislodge the monster". Not in voiceover, but in on-screen tips.

Really? Dodge the monster? You know what would have happened in a game like this ten years ago? If you were too dumb to move out of the way of the twenty foot thick tentacles swinging in your direction? You fucking DIED, that's what happened. It was up to the player to decide they needed to dodge, the game didn't have to tell you to do it.

What scares me about this is that they probably figured this out in playtesting, that the testers became frustrated and called the game "too hard" because they couldn't figure out the basic premise of "don't stand in the fire". So the developers, no slouches themselves at how to make good games, ended up having to "dumb it down" so little Johnny wouldn't throw his controller out of the window.

The other example is the upcoming Tomb Raider reboot. On the one hand, the game looks very good, and could be a promising kick start to an otherwise aging franchise that isn't doing so well. On the other hand, it's also made for the "stupid gamer".

I was watching a demo of this one as well, and our stalwart heroine Lara Croft makes her way into a cavern. There's various mechanical contraptions, elevators and the like, and Lara has to figure out how to make use of them to get up to the exit from the cave.

Or rather, she doesn't have to figure it out.

On entering the cavern, the game actually highlights exactly where she needs to go and what to do when she gets there. Literally, it's a brightly glowing lever that's impossible for the player to miss. Just walk up, push the button to flip the lever, and the elevator activates, allowing Lara to jump up to the next level. Takes all of thirty seconds. They call this Lara's "survival sense".

Again, I have to hearken back to games from aeons ago. And not just any random adventure game, I mean this very franchise, the first Tomb Raider game, released for the original Playstation in 1996. I played this game myself, a lot, and I loved it. You'd walk into a cavern, maybe very similar to the one in this new game, and you'd spend half an hour trying to figure out how to get on that upper level, and you had to use your own damn wits to do it.

So which is better? That you have to figure it out for yourself, or that the game simply tells you what to do? The original Tomb Raider was, at its heart, a puzzle game built into the framework of an action/adventure title. There were huge sections of the game without enemies, just an environment that the player had to work their way through. And yes, it was challenging. Yes, it was sometimes frustrating. But dammit, when you hit the exit, you felt like you really accomplished something. You figured that shit out on your own and you felt good about it.

What happens when you don't have to figure it out anymore? What's the point? It's like reading a game guide or watching a YouTube video on exactly how to solve the next puzzle before you even attempt it yourself. Where's the sense of accomplishment? The satisfaction of having solved the puzzle, having beaten the developers who were trying to stop you.. that was something special. And it's completely gone from this new Tomb Raider game. Just... gone. When you're done with this, there won't be any satisfaction, no patting yourself on the back. Just... nothing.

Is this where we're headed? If this game does well, which it probably will thanks to the already aggressive marketing they're doing, then the developers will just continue to make games like this. And the games that require the player to actually think will fall by the wayside. Some people just can't seem to wrap their head around "thinking" games anymore. I remember reading a discussion a few years ago, after the first Portal game was released and made a huge splash in the game industry. One player in particular finished the game and said it was "boring" and "nothing special". When prompted, he had no problem admitting that he had used online guides for every single puzzle. Every. Single. One. He didn't solve a single room on his own. It's a puzzle game, for crying out loud.. if you don't actually solve the puzzles, then can you honestly say that you really played the game at all? And what happens when the game itself gives you the answer? Is it really even a game anymore?

Check out THIS VIDEO to see just how much things have changed, and not for the better.

Sunday, February 19, 2012

Dragon Tattoo? Seen it already.

So there's been a lot of buzz about The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. My opinion is "whatever". The reason for that is simple: I've already seen it. I saw it before it even hit theaters here.

I saw it back when it was called Män som hatar kvinnor.

Oh, but it's a different movie, you say.. a different take on the idea. My answer? I don't care. The story's the same, I already know how it ends.

It's fairly common that our initial impression of something comes to define our idea of it. In the case of this film, it's the actors and their performances. For me, Noomi Rapace is Lisbeth Salander. Michael Nyqvist is Mikael Blomkvist. Period, the end.

Hollywood has this habit of spending lots of money remaking so-called "foreign" films. Effectively doing little but re-recording the film with English dialogue, for the Michael Bay Generation that can't be bothered to do something as simple as read.

I use the phrase "so-called foreign films" to point out that there are almost no "domestic" films anymore. Almost all films are produced overseas, usually in Europe, Australia, New Zealand, etc, using non-American actors, financed by non-American companies, written and directed by non-American writers and producers. But they're not "foreign" films.. because they're in English. Record a film here in the States, 100% home-grown American, but do it in Spanish instead? Bam.. "foreign film". They really need to clarify this.. they're only called "foreign" because they're filmed in a language other than English.

So they think that we stupid Americans can't read, so they make the film in English. And then they totally bork (or börk?) up the casting. Granted, I don't really know Rooney Mara that well, having only seen her in Nightmare on Elm Street, where I would classify her performance as "okay" (considering the material). She's got her work cut out here, because Lisbeth is not an easy role by any means, and a role like this can make or break a career. To be fair, I have heard good things about her performance, but I'm not sure if they're making comparisons to Noomi Rapace, who, for many people (including me), cemented who Lisbeth is. But Daniel Craig? Sorry, but he would be one of the last people I would cast as Blomkvist. Michael Nyqvist might not be the American "pretty boy", but the man can act, and his performance as Blomkvist absolutely makes him into a real person that the audience can really believe. Daniel Craig is great if you put him in the right role, but this is not it.

I just fail to see the point of the whole "remake" thing. Män som hatar kvinnor (which, incidentally, does not translate as "The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo") is barely three years old. Aside from the language "barrier", there's absolutely no reason to make the whole thing again. It's not like the originals were low-budget backyard productions.. they're extremely well made by any measure, and are all-around good films.

And most people here in the States are barely aware that they exist, and they'll probably never see them. They're on Netflix right now, all three of them. I wonder what the viewing numbers look like for them. Probably numbers that would make me sad.


Sunday, February 12, 2012

The Michael Bay Generation (Is Filmmaking Dead?)

So I'm reading this thread on a message board about movies, and I see someone say "Oh, that movie's boring.. I could barely stay awake through it." Something I've seen repeated several times, about this film in particular.

Is it boring? Not really, no. It's quite engaging, actually. But it does two things that seem to be anathema to the average moviegoer these days:

1) It doesn't have boobies or explosions.
2) It actually makes you put the pieces of the plot together yourself instead of just handing it to you on a silver platter.

The film in question? The recent spy thriller Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy.

I refer to this phenomenon as the "Michael Bay Generation". Although Bay is not directly responsible for the phenomenon, his films are the most obvious example of it. Like a lot of entertainment genres these days, including television, reading, and gaming, people seem to want the "spectacle" more than the "art".

Case in point: Transformers: Dark of the Moon. Total box office take worldwide, over one billion dollars. Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy? Fifty-six million. It seems that people just don't want films like this anymore.

Let's examine TTSS for a minute. Surprisingly short at barely two hours, I fully expected it to be quite a bit longer. It's a spy thriller taking place in and around British Intelligence (MI6) during the Cold War in 1973. It features an absolutely stellar cast, including Gary Oldman, Colin Firth, Tom Hardy, Mark Strong, Ciarán Hinds, Benedict Cumberbatch, and John Hurt, all of which turn in spectacular performances. Gary Oldman is looking at an Oscar nomination (his first, surprisingly) for this role, and it's well deserved.

The "problem" with the film, according to the Michael Bay Generation, is that it's a true spy movie. The way spies actually work in the real world. This isn't James Bond's MI6. This is a bunch of guys talking about sources of information and deciding how to act on it. It describes the recruitment process, and how normally uneventful spying really is. Sneaking into an office and making off with a folder full of information instead of parachuting into a villain's lair and killing forty-seven people using a watch with a laser in it. One of the most tense moments in TTSS is literally a character trying to distract the people around him so he can stuff a pile of paper into his briefcase. And it works because it's so brilliantly edited and acted, you really feel the tension that the character feels, and you know that he (and you) will just die if someone suddenly pipes up and says "Oy, what you doin' there?" The character almost has a nervous breakdown afterwards, and you really believe it.

So there's no big explosions or fight scenes. I think there's a total of maybe four gunshots throughout the entire film. Exciting, in the Michael Bay sense? No, definitely not. Gripping and enthralling through story and acting? Absolutely.

And yes, no boobies. There's only a few mentions of sex throughout the entire film, and it's seen through the eyes of a very jaded and somewhat bitter middle-aged man who's dealing with his own issues. So no "Bond girls", either. The one woman we feel even the slightest bit of concern for throughout the film is brutally murdered right in front of us.

Another thing that TTSS does is make you think things out on your own. It's a spy movie, after all, a real spy movie. I knew going into it that the plot was probably going to be extremely complicated, so I was prepared for it when it turned out to be exactly that. Yeah, a lot of it gets explained at the end, but the pieces are always there if you look. It's a film with a lot of different threads going on, and they don't really start to come together until the film's climax. And even then, it's not all just handed to the audience.. there's still little pieces you need to think about on your own if you want an answer.

It's a really sad thing that a film like this will simply be labeled as "boring" (along with other "boring" films like The Godfather, I suppose), and will probably disappear into the bargain bin, and will force Hollywood to stop producing them. It really is an exceptional piece of filmmaking, and if you have it in you to appreciate good films.. not "spectacles" or "event films", but just really good films, then you owe it yourself to see this one.

Sunday, January 15, 2012

Violent video games - Is it the problem "they" say it is?

Hot topic! This one comes up all the time, usually after someone kills someone else (in real life). I've been chewing on this one for a while.

Proponents of this theory say that violent video games cause violent behavior. That little Johnny was such an angel until he started playing Grand Theft Auto, at which point he went next door and stabbed little Stevie to death with a carving fork.

These people are idiots. And yes, I'm going to tell you why.

For one, they try to prove their point by doing studies that prove a link between violent behavior and the playing of violent video games. Jimmy is a bully at school, and he plays a video game called Bully. In the game, you're tasked with being a bully at school, and sure enough, Jimmy is a bully in real life. Proven. Or is it?

Now, I'm not saying that there isn't a link between violent behavior and violent games. Just that these people have it backwards:

Jimmy isn't a bully because he plays the game. He plays the game because he's a bully.

A slight change in wording makes a HUGE difference in the outcome. The truth is quite simple: Violent people are more attracted to violent video games. It's not the other way around. The video games don't make them into violent people, they're already violent people, whether they play the game or not.

This could be proven rather easily by just doing a simple unbiased study. You put Jimmy the bully and Bobby the little angel into a room to play video games, and you give them a choice of Saint's Row and Barbie Horse Adventures. Guess which kid's going to play which one? Jimmy isn't going to touch the Barbie game with a ten-foot pole, and if you were to force it on him, he'd probably try to find ways in which to break the horse's legs so he'd get to shoot it. Conversely, if you were to force angel Bobby to play Saint's Row to run over pedestrians and shoot up a police station, he'd probably get sick. He'd play the game in a very conservative fashion, and he absolutely would not suddenly turn into a mass murderer.

In fact, other studies have been done that indicate that violent video games are actually a healthy outlet for aggression for these people. Have a bad day at work? Pop in Call of Duty and go kill some Russkies, you'll feel better. Better to play a game for an hour than to leave a body in a ditch somewhere, yeah?

Yes, I play violent video games. Because I'm a violent person. I have an incredibly vicious temper, one that I've had since long before these games even existed, that I've spent most of my life learning to control. And I'm very good at it. Most people see me as mild-mannered Clark Kent, which is how I prefer to be.. it's who I want to be. That's the guy that plays Flower. Underneath, it's more like Dexter Morgan. He's the one that plays Mortal Kombat.

The problem is that a lot of parents these days, specifically the ones that were never gamers themselves, believe that games never grew up.. they think that it's all still Pac-Man and Missle Command and that "games are for kids". As such, they tend to completely ignore the rating system (many aren't even aware that there is such a thing) and let their kids play whatever they want. Ironically, they get mad at the store or the game industry when they find out just what the games are like, even though they themselves purchased it. It's not that hard, really. If the store clerk refuses to sell the game to Junior, and asks for your ID before selling it to you, that might be a pretty good indication that this game isn't what you think it is.

It's part of a much larger problem of parents refusing to take responsibility for the raising of their children, but that's a discussion for another time.

In the meantime, parents need to pay attention to what their kids are playing, and learn about the rating system. It's there for a reason. Video games aren't for kids anymore.

Friday, September 16, 2011

Ads in Deus Ex - Dubya Tee Eff

Allow me to toss out a WTF moment. Yesterday Square Enix releases a patch for the PC version of Deus Ex: Human Revolution that, among other things, fixes some horrible performance bugs that have plagued the game since launch. So obviously, everybody wants to download the patch as soon as possible.

One other "feature", that wasn't mentioned in the patch notes, is the new in-game advertising system! Yes, the fifty bucks that I already paid for the game apparently isn't good enough. Now they want to show me real-world advertising on the loading screens. Yay for immersion.

Bear in mind that advertising is, in general, one of my pet peeves. I absolutely hate.. nay, despise being told what I should buy. You're not telling me anything about the product that I care to hear. If I don't already know about it through word-of-mouth (which, on the internet, is extensive, and I hang out at all the places that will have first news of anything that interests me), then it's clearly not worth my time or money. And if I do hear about it through word-of-mouth, I'll do my own research, and then I'll make up my own mind about whether to purchase your product. Therefore, I simply don't do ads, period. I have more ad-blockers installed than I know what to do with, and I frantically perma-ban anything that slips through that minefield.

So why in the holy hell would I want to see real-world advertisements in my games? If the game were free-to-play, I could understand it, although most FTP developers use other methods for profit generation than advertisements. Valve, for example, sells in-game hats that your Team Fortress characters can wear. Silly, yes, but it works, and you're not forced into it.. it's a cosmetic thing. But no.. I'm loading up the next level in DXHR, and there it is.. "Buy the Star Wars Blu-ray!!"

Really? The Star Wars Blu-ray? Do you think I live in a ***king cave? That I honestly was not aware the set existed? That I didn't already ***king own it? Of course I already own it. So why would I want to see anything.. ANYTHING telling me to run out and buy it again?

I'm waiting with baited breath to see what Square Enix has to say in its defense. Unless they want to refund my fifty bucks, their ads can go to hell.

One day later, and I've got a mod that blocks them. But what pisses me off the most is that I shouldn't have to do this for a game that I bought and paid for. It's like DVDs that don't let you fast-forward through the trailers for movies that came out six years ago. It's stupid.

You can download the mod HERE. I recommend everybody do it. And send a nasty letter to Square Enix while you're at it.

I'm out.